Carriers

With access to several of the largest and most respected companies, we are confident we can find the best coverage and rates for you. Use the links below to see more information about a company. Many of the companies we represent offer online claims service and bill pay.

Auto-Owners Logo
Auto-Owners Insurance

Phone:

Claims:

517.323.1200

888.252.4626

American West Logo
American West

Phone:

800.668.4340

Cincinnati Insurance Logo
Cincinnati Insurance

Phone:

Claims:

888.242.8811

877.242.2544

Columbia Insurance Group Logo
Columbia Insurance Group

Continental Western Logo
Continental Western

Phone:

800.235.2942

Dakota Farm Mutual Logo
Dakota Farm Mutual Insurance Company

Phone:

866.876.2942

Farmers Mutual Insurance of Nebraska Logo
Farmers Mutual Insurance of Nebraska

Phone:

Claims:

402.434.8300

800.742.7433

Grinnell Mutual Logo
Grinnell Mutual

Phone:

Claims:

800.362.2041

877.467.2252

Hagerty Insurance Logo
Hagerty Insurance

Phone:

Claims:

877.922.9701

800.922.4050

Humboldt Farm Mutual Logo
Humboldt Farm Mutual Insurance Company

Phone:

866.876.2942

Kemper Preferred Logo
Kemper Preferred

Phone:

Claims:

877.252.7878

888.252.2799

North Star Mutual Logo
North Star Mutual

Phone:

800.622.5230

Progressive Insurance Logo
Progressive Insurance

Phone:

Claims:

800.776.4737

800.274.4499

Roberts Mutual Logo
Roberts Mutual Insurance

Phone:

605.698.7122

OFFICE LOCATIONS

Watertown Branch

1608 9th Ave SW

Watertown, SD 57201

Phone: (605) 886-9319 

Fax: (605) 886-9356

Hartford Branch

101 E 2nd St.

Hartford, SD 57033

Phone: (605) 528-6816

Fax: (605) 528-3323

DBA Insurance Store

211 South Main

Howard, SD 57349

Phone: (605) 772-4448

Fax: (605) 772-5785

©

©

Puthoff Insurance Agency | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy